Reviewer Guidelines
Jurnal Lentera Kesehatan Masyarakat (JLKM) uses double-blind peer review. Reviewers must provide independent, objective, constructive, and timely assessments.
Before Accepting a Review
- Accept only manuscripts within your expertise and available time.
- Disclose financial, personal, professional, institutional, or other conflicts of interest; decline the review when independence could be affected.
- Notify the editor if an author's identity is apparent. Do not attempt to identify or contact authors.
Confidentiality and Artificial Intelligence
Manuscripts, supplementary files, review reports, and editorial correspondence are confidential. Reviewers must not share or use unpublished material. Manuscripts must not be uploaded to public or external generative-AI systems where confidentiality, privacy, or intellectual property could be compromised. Any permitted technical assistance must not replace the reviewer's own judgment, and the reviewer remains accountable for the report.
Assessment Criteria
- Evaluate originality, relevance, methods, research ethics, analysis, reporting, interpretation, limitations, references, and conclusions.
- Check whether the title, abstract, tables, figures, and conclusions accurately reflect the work.
- Distinguish essential corrections from optional suggestions and give clear, evidence-based reasons.
- Use respectful, specific, and non-discriminatory language.
- Do not request irrelevant citations, including self-citations, or changes intended to advance personal interests.
Assessing Public-Health Studies
- Check the study population, setting, sampling approach, and relevance to the public-health question.
- Assess how exposures, outcomes, and key variables are defined, and whether the instruments and analysis suit the design. Consider missing data, bias, confounding, and the limits of interpretation where applicable.
- For qualitative research, examine the explanation of participant selection, data collection, analysis, and the evidence supporting the themes.
- For community programs or health-service evaluations, check whether objectives, implementation, findings, and practical implications are supported by an appropriate evaluation.
- Consider ethics approval, consent, confidentiality, and safeguards for vulnerable participants or sensitive workplace and health records.
Structuring the Review Report
Provide a short assessment of the study's contribution, followed by numbered major and minor comments. Explain why each substantive change is needed and give enough detail for authors to respond. Send confidential integrity concerns to the editor separately from comments intended for authors.
Research Integrity Concerns
Confidentially alert the editor to suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or falsified data, unethical research, image manipulation, inappropriate citation practices, or substantial overlap. Reviewers must not conduct an independent investigation or contact third parties.
Recommendation and Revision
Select the recommendation supported by the report: accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject. The editor makes the final decision. When invited to assess a revision, reviewers should focus on whether the authors have addressed the substantive concerns and whether any new issues affect the reliability of the work.
Related guidance: review and editorial workflow; responsible use of AI; competing interests.